Excitement is in the air when a group from Sparrow Island, including Abby and Mary, set off for Seattle for a taping of the roaming appraisal show Antique Adventures. But when a valuable teapot disappears, Finnegan goes missing and Abby's bird print—a suspected Audubon—vanishes from her hotel room, Abby is determined to find the thief. A careless detective and some suspicious members of the show's crew make her investigation difficult, and a handsome stranger complicates matters of a more personal nature. Meanwhile, Mary's heirloom treasure leads the sisters to hidden secrets of their family's past. Can Abby see through the greed, jealousy and lies to show the group that the true treasures in life are faith and friendship?